My Soul to Take (2010) R
Film Filter: On- On the same night that a schizophrenic serial killer takes the life of his wife, seven children in the town of Riverton are born. Sixteen years later, the Riverton Seven start to become murdered one by one on their collective birthday, leading them to believe the spirit of The Ripper is among them. They begin to look at each other as suspects while they wonder how many of them will be forced to die before the killer's identity is revealed.
Things to note: Many plot twists, interesting lead character, several suspects as murderer, cheesy deaths, not many scary moments.
You'll like this movie if you enjoy:
Slasher films involving numerous victims and suspects.
Something like Scream, but with a tighter wound plot.